Project Proposal Review

A proposal is screened and signed by the portfolio manager, assessed in parallel for cost, technical feasibility and return, and then signed off by the steering committee chair.

Sign in with your Edesy account; the setup wizard opens on this template.

Category

Project Management

Type

Business process

Steps

10

Roles

Portfolio manager, Business analyst, Technical lead, Finance analyst, Steering committee chair

Level

Advanced, about 15 min to set up

How the workflow runs

Good proposals deserve a fair, evidence-based decision. The proposer submits the problem, the proposed solution, the budget and the benefits. The portfolio manager screens it and signs to confirm it is worth assessing, and the proposer is told it has moved on. Three assessments then run at the same time: a business analyst estimates cost and effort, a technical lead checks feasibility and risk, and a finance analyst models the return. With all three in hand the steering committee chair makes the final, signed decision and the proposer hears the result.

DenyApproveMark as doneMark as doneMark as doneDenyApproveFormForm: Project ProposalApprove & sign · Portfolio managerScreen & sign:{{trigger.body.title}}E-mailE-mail: Proposal not takenforward: …E-mailE-mail: Your proposal is beingassessedSplitParallel assessmentsTask · Business analystEstimate scope, effort andcostTask · Technical leadAssess technical feasibilityTask · Finance analystModel the return on investmentApprove & sign · Steering committeSteering committee decision:{{trigger.body.title}}E-mailE-mail: Steering committeedecision: …E-mailE-mail: Funded: …

Steps in order

  1. 1

    Form: Project Proposal

    Starts the workflow

  2. 2

    Screen & sign: {{trigger.body.title}}

    Approve & sign · Portfolio manager

    Deny: E-mail: Proposal not taken forward: … · Approve: E-mail: Your proposal is being assessed

  3. 3

    E-mail: Proposal not taken forward: …

    E-mail

  4. 4

    E-mail: Your proposal is being assessed

    E-mail

  5. 5

    Parallel assessments

    Split

  6. 6

    Estimate scope, effort and cost

    Task · Business analyst

    Mark as done: Steering committee decision: {{trigger.body.title}}

  7. 7

    Assess technical feasibility

    Task · Technical lead

    Mark as done: Steering committee decision: {{trigger.body.title}}

  8. 8

    Model the return on investment

    Task · Finance analyst

    Mark as done: Steering committee decision: {{trigger.body.title}}

  9. 9

    Steering committee decision: {{trigger.body.title}}

    Approve & sign · Steering committee chair

    Deny: E-mail: Steering committee decision: … · Approve: E-mail: Funded: …

  10. 10

    E-mail: Steering committee decision: …

    E-mail

  11. 11

    E-mail: Funded: …

    E-mail

Forms

  • Project Proposal

    Starts the workflow · 12 questions

Who takes part

  • Portfolio manager
  • Business analyst
  • Technical lead
  • Finance analyst
  • Steering committee chair

Project Proposal Review: questions

You sign in to Edesy Flow with your Edesy account and the template wizard opens: map each role to a person, pick the app connections it needs, and Flow creates the forms and the workflow for you to edit.

Yes. The workflow opens in the visual builder, where you can add, remove or reorder steps, change who approves, edit the e-mails and add branches.

Related templates